• About us
  • Our news
  • People
  • Practice areas
  • Recognitions
  • Career
  • Contact
  • About us
  • Our news
  • People
  • Practice areas
  • Recognitions
  • Career
  • Contact
  • ET
  • EN
  • RU

Practice areas

  • Tax

    Tax

    Tax, Customs

    Our tax specialists, some with prior experience of working for the tax authorities, advise and represent clients in all issues related to tax and customs law: structuring transactions, relations with tax authorities and tax disputes (i.a. tax crimes). The vast and highly recognised experience with tax disputes allows us to foresee and address the potential risks already prior to executing transactions.

    Latvia

    Partners
    • Aivar Pilv
    • Pirkka-Marja Põldvere
    • Merilin Ojasaar
    • Marko Pilv
    Senior Associates
    • Epp Lumiste
    • Oleg Matvejev
    Associates
    • Kaili Rätsepp
    • Artur Viira
    Support staff
    • Marina Pilv
    • Ene Eesik
    • Reelika Vaiksaar
  • Regulatory & compliance

    Regulatory & compliance

    Administrative proceedings, Consumer protection, Data protection, Energy, Sports

    Given the ever-expanding set of local and international rules and regulations which impact the daily lives of companies of all sizes, compliance has been getting more and more attention as a potential source of corporate issues. Our team of specialists has vast experience in helping our clients to understand and deal as efficiently as possible with all the rules and regulations that apply to them.

    Latvia

    Partners
    • Aivar Pilv
    • Pirkka-Marja Põldvere
    • Merilin Ojasaar
    • Marko Pilv
    Senior Associates
    • Epp Lumiste
    • Oleg Matvejev
    Associates
    • Kaili Rätsepp
    • Artur Viira
    Support staff
    • Marina Pilv
    • Ene Eesik
    • Reelika Vaiksaar
  • Real estate & construction

    Real estate & construction

    Construction, Zoning and planning, Infrastructure, Environment, Real estate

    Our practice includes counselling on a variety of real estate related issues: real estate development (i.a. zoning & planning, permits, infrastructure, construction contracts, financing, environment), rights and obligations stemming from ownership (e.g. co-ownership, servitudes, access roads), as well as rent and lease of immovables. International publications have, for years, recognised our professionalism in dealing with these matters.

    Latvia

    Partners
    • Aivar Pilv
    • Pirkka-Marja Põldvere
    • Merilin Ojasaar
    • Marko Pilv
    Senior Associates
    • Epp Lumiste
    • Oleg Matvejev
    Associates
    • Kaili Rätsepp
    • Artur Viira
    Support staff
    • Marina Pilv
    • Ene Eesik
    • Reelika Vaiksaar
  • Mergers & Acquisitions

    Mergers & Acquisitions

    Mergers & Acquisitions (M&A)

    We assist our clients in all stages of M&A transactions, i.a. negotiations, project management, structuring of the transaction, conducting legal due diligence and other preparations, execution of necessary documentation, as well as closing of transactions. We also advise our clients on creating joint ventures. Our M&A team has experience in providing practical solutions in the most complex issues. We have advised all kinds of companies and our M&A team has participated in a number of transactions in all the Baltic countries and also covering outside targets.

    Latvia

    Partners
    • Aivar Pilv
    • Pirkka-Marja Põldvere
    • Merilin Ojasaar
    • Marko Pilv
    Senior Associates
    • Epp Lumiste
    • Oleg Matvejev
    Associates
    • Kaili Rätsepp
    • Artur Viira
    Support staff
    • Marina Pilv
    • Ene Eesik
    • Reelika Vaiksaar
  • Medical & pharmaceuticals

    Medical & pharmaceuticals

    Health care, Medical & pharmaceuticals

    We provide legal advice and represent our clients in all matters related to pharmaceuticals, which is one of the fastest growing industries with rapidly changing rules and regulations that varies from one country to another. Our attorneys, in cooperation with medical field professionals, advise on a regular basis on the requirements for manufacturing medical products, the promotion of medical products and requirements for performance of clinical trials. We also have a comprehensive practice in representing clients in medical malpractice cases.

    Latvia

    Partners
    • Aivar Pilv
    • Pirkka-Marja Põldvere
    • Merilin Ojasaar
    • Marko Pilv
    Senior Associates
    • Epp Lumiste
    • Oleg Matvejev
    Associates
    • Kaili Rätsepp
    • Artur Viira
    Support staff
    • Marina Pilv
    • Ene Eesik
    • Reelika Vaiksaar
  • IT & intellectual property

    IT & intellectual property

    Information technology, Telecommunications, Media, Intellectual property

    We keep up with the times and acknowledge the vast use of information technologies and the growing importance of intellectual property in today’s business. With individual approach and by looking from clients’ perspective, our team can provide advice on all aspects related to information technologies and intellectual property. We combine our knowledge of conventional business transactions with an in-depth understanding of the related technical aspects. Our attorneys are recognised for having experience e.g. in legal aspects of cloud computing, software licencing and patent registration.

    Latvia

    Partners
    • Aivar Pilv
    • Pirkka-Marja Põldvere
    • Merilin Ojasaar
    • Marko Pilv
    Senior Associates
    • Epp Lumiste
    • Oleg Matvejev
    Associates
    • Kaili Rätsepp
    • Artur Viira
    Support staff
    • Marina Pilv
    • Ene Eesik
    • Reelika Vaiksaar
  • Dispute resolution

    Dispute resolution

    Litigation, Arbitration, Alternative dispute resolution, Family and inheritance, Enforcement, White-collar crimes

    We have a comprehensive practice in litigation, arbitration, as well as out-of-court debt recovery. Our attorneys are regularly acting as arbitrators, conciliators and bankruptcy trustees. Many of our cases have principally changed the interpretation of law, being often also of interest to the general public. International publications have, for years, recognised us as among top dispute resolution firms on the market.

    Latvia

    Partners
    • Aivar Pilv
    • Pirkka-Marja Põldvere
    • Merilin Ojasaar
    • Marko Pilv
    Senior Associates
    • Epp Lumiste
    • Oleg Matvejev
    Associates
    • Kaili Rätsepp
    • Artur Viira
    Support staff
    • Marina Pilv
    • Ene Eesik
    • Reelika Vaiksaar
  • Corporate & commercial

    Corporate & commercial

    Corporate governance, Public procurement, Public-private partnerships, Transactions and trade, Competition, Employment, Migration, Transport

    Our group of specialists provides top-quality counselling on various aspects of corporate and commercial law: corporate governance, transactions and trade, public procurement, public-private partnerships, competition etc. Our clients range from some of the largest companies in the market to small start-ups, and thus the advised issues vary respectively. Our competence has been consistently recognized as one of the best in the market by annual international publications.

    Latvia

    Partners
    • Aivar Pilv
    • Pirkka-Marja Põldvere
    • Merilin Ojasaar
    • Marko Pilv
    Senior Associates
    • Epp Lumiste
    • Oleg Matvejev
    Associates
    • Kaili Rätsepp
    • Artur Viira
    Support staff
    • Marina Pilv
    • Ene Eesik
    • Reelika Vaiksaar
  • Banking & finance

    Banking & finance

    Finance, Banking, Securities, Insurance, Investment, Insolvency, Debt restructuring and recovery

    We advise banks and other financial institutions in all matters related to financial transactions and supervision. International publications recognise LEADELL offices as among leading law firms in advising on debt restructuring and rescheduling. The experience gained by advising leading banks of the Baltics allows our team to adequately address the interests of all parties to a transaction, as well as requirements applicable to them. Our team is also competent in counselling on fintech matters that have arisen due to the radical changes in traditional financial services caused by digital innovations.

    Latvia

    Partners
    • Aivar Pilv
    • Pirkka-Marja Põldvere
    • Merilin Ojasaar
    • Marko Pilv
    Senior Associates
    • Epp Lumiste
    • Oleg Matvejev
    Associates
    • Kaili Rätsepp
    • Artur Viira
    Support staff
    • Marina Pilv
    • Ene Eesik
    • Reelika Vaiksaar
    • ET
    • EN
    • RU
  • AB
  • AB
  • About us
  • Our news
  • People
  • Practice areas
  • Recognitions
  • Career
  • Contact

Our Experience

News

Attorney Aleksandr Tsemin explains if community of apartment owners has any right to claim from a new owner of property a debt that belongs to a previous owner

01.03.2017LEADELL

Attorney from law office LEADELL Pilv Aleksandr Tsemin has written an article in web publication of Postimees magazine, the topic of which: “Is new owner of an apartment obliged to pay old debts?”.

There are only a few apartment buildings where amongst the residents prevails total consensus,  as well as compulsory taxes are paid timely and to full extent. Regardless of payment discipline, community of apartment owners has to fulfil its obligations concerning both members of community and the service providers. Unpaid debts are executed by community members, thus the community has to claim all the household expenses from obligors. But how one should behave, if obligor transfers a property after court sentenced obligor to pay the debt for the benefit of community? If it is possible to get this debt from a new apartment’s owner on the basis of a judgement connected to the previous owner?

The first-time assessment of the Supreme Court

The Supreme Court has recently published an assessment of the possibility for community of apartment owners to claim the debt from a new owner by execution process on the basis of judgement that had been used to collect the debt from previous owner. In this decision The supreme Court detected that the new owner is not a legal successor of the previous one, rather he is a solidary responsible –  that means that the new owner’s responsibility occurs just in a raw with the responsibility of previous one_ but not instead of it. Consequently, it is not possible to apply earlier judgement as enforcement order for debt claiming from a person, who acquired the apartment ownership later. In other words, the community of apartment owners has to file the same claim with court again. Unfortunately, there is still no clear answer in the court practice, if the debt expired, when it had been formed, for instance, 4 years before an apartment was transferred. Thus, the absence of legal regulations in this case makes it complicated for legal defence of the community of apartment owners.

From the standpoint of expiry issue, it is significantly important to define the basis for arising acquirer’s solidary responsibility. Following the regulations of the Supreme Court, it is possible to assume, that this relationship is covered by the Article 65 of Law of Obligations Act. In this case the situation for community of apartment owners is extremely unfavourable. In the light of this article, the unnamed facts, that impact the responsibility of solidary obligors, particularly the expiry date objection, are applied to this solidary obligor to whom they concern, if other is not stated by law. Therefore, if the claim against one of the obligors is satisfied as well as expiry is stopped (court decision can be fulfilled within 10 years), it doesn’t impact anyhow the new owner. The claims against the new owner can be expired before he acquired a new flat, which means community will never get the debt back.

New owner as a surety

In contrast, a fundamentally different situation occurs, if to consider Apartment Ownership Act that came into force in 2014, on the basis of which the new owner bears responsibility acting as a surety for unpaid bills of a previous owner. If to consider new owner as a surety, then his acquirer’s obligation arises separately from secured principal obligation. A surety can submit objections, that are based on obligee and obligor relationship or on suretyship. In other words, in case community of apartment owners was diligent and filed a claim against previous owner, the expiry of claims stops with regards to principal obligor (the court decision can be fulfilled within 10 years). A surety can therefore submit objections that only arise from suretyship. As the new owner gets into position of surety only at the stage of acquisition process,  community has the right to file the same claim with court against new owner of the property within 3 years.

One has to be active oneself

The above mentioned solutions are only a part of existing alternatives. Hopefully the Supreme Court will provide its assessment to above described legal problems sooner or later, however, it is reasonable for the community of apartment owners to apply the following  diligence measures:

  • Community has to be active and do not let the debt grow. It is highly recommended to have recourse to court straight after debt appears;
  • Community has to fulfil the judgement immediately, that sentenced to collect debt from obligor, and charge it the connected with it apartment, if necessary;
  • The community must claim the debt payment from the new owner immediately after property is transferred.

 

Financial resources of community are modified of all of the paid amounts by all owners. In case some of the owners don’t pay the bills, then those bills are paid by other owners. It is obvious that this situation hurt the sense of justice of community members. As a result of increased financial burden, the smaller communities can stay without some important renovating works that impact a lot the quality of living of all the members. Bearing this in mind, the community of apartment owners should be active while defencing own rights and do not postpone the collection of debt.

  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter

Categories

  • All
  • International recognition
  • Office news
  • Tax
  • Real estate & construction
  • Dispute resolution
  • IT & intellectual property
  • Regulatory & compliance
  • Corporate & commercial
  • Seminars trainings

Subscribe to Leadell's Newsletter

    Maakri 19/1, P.O. Box 19
    10145 Tallinn, Estonia
    Tel.+ 372 619 1630
    E-mail: tallinn@leadell.com

    • M_rgisENG